COSHH and Air Monitoring FAQs
When is COSHH air monitoring required?
COSHH air monitoring may be required where it is necessary to demonstrate that exposure to a hazardous substance is adequately controlled or where exposure needs to be compared with a Workplace Exposure Limit.
Monitoring may also be appropriate to:
- Investigate employee exposure
- Demonstrate the effectiveness of control measures
- Assess local exhaust ventilation
- Investigate changes in processes
- Confirm that exposure is adequately controlled
- Investigate unexpected or uncertain exposure
Not every hazardous substance requires routine air monitoring. The need should be determined by the COSHH assessment and the circumstances of exposure.
How do I know if I need workplace air monitoring?
Workplace air monitoring may be appropriate when there is uncertainty about employee exposure or where exposure could approach a Workplace Exposure Limit.
It can also be useful where:
- Existing controls need to be validated
- A process has changed
- New materials have been introduced
- LEV effectiveness is uncertain
- Employees are reporting symptoms or concerns
- Exposure to carcinogens, asthmagens or other significant hazards needs to be investigated
An occupational hygienist can review the process and COSHH assessment and determine whether monitoring is necessary and what sampling strategy is appropriate.
How much does workplace air monitoring cost?
The cost of workplace air monitoring depends on the substances being assessed, the number of employees, sampling duration, number of samples and analytical requirements.
Some substances can be monitored relatively simply, whereas others require specialist sampling equipment and laboratory analysis.
The appropriate monitoring strategy should therefore be established before a quotation is prepared.
Validate Consulting can review your workplace processes and monitoring requirements and provide a quotation based on the actual scope of work.
How do you measure employees' exposure to hazardous substances?
The most common approach is personal air sampling, where a sampling pump is worn by an employee and collects air from their breathing zone during representative work.
Depending on the substance and purpose of the assessment, other techniques can include:
- Static air sampling
- Direct-reading instruments
- Surface sampling
- Biological monitoring
Personal sampling is particularly valuable because it provides information about the concentration of a contaminant in the air actually being inhaled by the worker.
The sampling strategy should reflect the employee’s normal work and the variability of exposure.
What is personal exposure monitoring?
Personal exposure monitoring measures the concentration of a hazardous substance in the breathing zone of an individual worker during their normal work.
It can be used to estimate exposure and, where appropriate, compare the results with relevant Workplace Exposure Limits.
Personal monitoring is particularly useful where employees move around the workplace, perform multiple tasks or experience variable exposure.
The results can help determine whether existing controls are effective and whether additional control measures are required.
What is the difference between personal and static air sampling?
Personal air sampling measures exposure in the worker’s breathing zone and is primarily used to assess individual exposure.
Static air sampling measures air at a fixed location. It can be useful for investigating contaminant sources, workplace concentrations and how contaminants move through an environment.
Static measurements do not necessarily represent an individual’s exposure.
If the question is “What is this employee exposed to?”, personal sampling is generally the more appropriate approach.
If the question is “Where is the contaminant coming from?”, static monitoring may provide useful additional information.
In many investigations, the two approaches can complement each other.
How long should workplace air monitoring be carried out for?
The appropriate sampling duration depends on the substance, exposure limit, work pattern and purpose of the assessment.
Long-term exposure assessments generally require sampling designed to represent the relevant working period, while short-term sampling may be appropriate where short-term exposure limits or peak exposures are important.
Representative sampling for a shift typically can be 6-8 hours in duration.
Where exposure varies significantly between tasks, shifts or employees, the sampling strategy should reflect that variability.
The objective is to obtain representative exposure information, rather than simply collecting samples for a convenient period.
How often should COSHH air monitoring be repeated?
Generally, the frequency of testing should be related to the hazard of the substance and whether previous assessments determine that control was not achieved or needs to be improved.
There is no universal monitoring interval that applies to every workplace or substance.
Monitoring should be repeated where there is reason to believe that exposure may have changed or where periodic monitoring is required to demonstrate that control remains effective.
Triggers can include:
- Changes to processes
- New substances
- Changes to production
- Changes to LEV
- Changes to working practices
- Changes to equipment
- Significant changes to the workforce
- Previous results indicating significant exposure
Monitoring frequency should therefore be risk-based rather than automatically annual.
What are Workplace Exposure Limits and how are they used?
Workplace Exposure Limits, or WELs, are airborne concentrations of hazardous substances intended to help control occupational exposure. They can be found in an HSE document “EH40/2005 Workplace Exposure Limits”
They are generally expressed as concentrations averaged over a specified period, including long-term and short-term exposure periods where applicable.
WELs can be used as part of workplace exposure assessment and to help determine whether existing controls are adequate.
However, being below a WEL does not automatically mean that no further control is required. Exposure should generally be reduced as far as reasonably practicable, particularly for substances with serious health effects.
What should I do if workplace air monitoring shows exposure above the WEL?
An exposure result above the relevant WEL should trigger an immediate investigation and action.
The first step is to understand the result and confirm that the monitoring was representative. The source of exposure and effectiveness of existing controls should then be investigated.
Control measures may include:
- Substitution
- Enclosure
- Process modification
- Improved LEV
- Improved maintenance
- Changes to working methods
- Reduced exposure duration
- Additional respiratory protection where appropriate
Further monitoring may be required to demonstrate that the revised controls have reduced exposure adequately.
How can I tell whether extraction is controlling exposure to dust or fumes?
There are several ways to assess whether local exhaust ventilation is controlling exposure effectively.
The LEV system must be examined to assess its condition and performance, while airflow measurements and smoke visualisation can provide information about capture effectiveness. This is called a “Thorough Examination and Test” or TExT, which has to be done every 14 months.
However, airflow measurements alone do not necessarily demonstrate that employee exposure is adequately controlled.
Personal air monitoring can provide additional evidence by measuring what employees are actually exposed to during the task.
The strongest assessment often combines LEV examination, observation of the process and occupational exposure monitoring.
Do I need air monitoring if employees use respiratory protective equipment (RPE)?
Yes.
The use of RPE does not automatically remove the need to understand workplace exposure. Air monitoring can help establish exposure levels outside the RPE and assess whether engineering and other controls are adequately controlling the hazard.
RPE is often not worn correctly, not cleaned or stored correctly or has outdated filters; the air monitoring assessment will review this but also determine if the correct mask is being worn and if it has the correct Assigned Protection Factor compared to the level of exposure.
Many times we have seen staff members use dust masks for control of vapours or gases.
RPE should generally be considered as part of a hierarchy of control rather than automatically being the primary solution.
What substances require air monitoring under COSHH?
There is no single list of substances for which air monitoring is automatically required.
The need for monitoring depends on the COSHH assessment, the properties of the substance, potential exposure and the effectiveness of existing controls.
Workplace air monitoring may be relevant to substances including:
- Wood dust
- Respirable crystalline silica
- Welding fume
- Solvent vapours
- Chemical vapours
- Dusts
- Mists
- Fumes
- Gases
- Specific substances with Workplace Exposure Limits
- ACMR’s (Asthmagens, Carcinogens, Mutagens and Reprotoxic substamces)
The appropriate sampling method depends on the substance and exposure scenario.
Can an occupational hygienist carry out COSHH air monitoring for my business?
Yes. A competent Occupational Hygienist can design and undertake workplace exposure monitoring and interpret the results in the context of COSHH.
Effective air monitoring involves considerably more than attaching a sampling pump to an employee.
The occupational hygienist should understand the process, identify the relevant hazards, select appropriate sampling and analytical methods, design a representative sampling strategy and interpret the results.
During the assessment, the consultant will be determining how the person is exposed and how effective the controls are, such as Air Extraction and any Respirators worn.
Validate Consulting provides COSHH exposure assessments and workplace air monitoring for a wide range of workplace contaminants.
Our objective is not simply to produce analytical results, but to explain what they mean and what, if anything, needs to be done.
Do I need air monitoring for wood dust?
Yes. Woodworking processes can generate significant airborne dust, with exposure depending on the type of wood, process, machinery, extraction and working practices.
A COSHH assessment should establish the potential exposure and determine whether existing controls are adequate.
Air monitoring can provide objective evidence of employee exposure and help demonstrate whether controls such as LEV are effective.
Monitoring may be particularly valuable where there is uncertainty about exposure, processes have changed, or there are concerns about the effectiveness of extraction.
Many companies we work with undertake monitoring to demonstrate that exposures are low and that the controls they have in place are working.
Do I need air monitoring for welding fumes?
Yes. Welding fumes can cause cancer and can generate complex mixtures of airborne contaminants.
Exposure depends on factors including:
- Welding process
- Base materials
- Welding consumables
- Surface coatings
- Ventilation
- LEV
- Working practices
- Duration of welding
A suitable assessment should identify the contaminants relevant to the particular process and determine whether monitoring is necessary.
Where exposure is significant, control should prioritise engineering measures, including effective local exhaust ventilation and appropriate process controls.
Many companies we work with undertake monitoring to demonstrate that exposures are low and that the controls they have in place are working.